Imagine having a childhood filled with love, joy, and warmth. Now, imagine what happens when that rug is swept right out from under you, causing you to crash painfully onto the floor and, even after you manage to get back up, your heart decides to stay - bloodied, broken, covered in cat hair and believing true love is the destroyer of lives. This is that story...but funnier. Martha Cooper is a beloved nurse during the week but spends her weekends as the lead singer for a popular cover band called The Cover Stealers. Thanks to a not-so-happy childhood, she keeps her romantic relationships casual and free from complications but, after years of being perfectly content with that situation, Logan Ashford enters her life and makes it clear he’s not looking for casual. Since Martha enjoys how she feels in his presence, she can’t bring herself to keep her distance but concocts a list of rules to abide by in order to protect her heart. While Logan’s charming and thoughtful nature chips away at said rules, Martha must make the difficult choice to pick her lint-covered heart back up off the floor or let go of her chance at true love.