The concept of trying to maintain a normal life after such a transformation is unique and refreshing, and Wickstrom explores it with vivid characterization, a touch for playful comedy (chapter 8 is titled “Still an Elk, Again”), and much whimsical dialogue. The dialogue, in fact, often drives the story and worldbuilding, trusting readers to supply imaginative context, although making sense of a world where everyone knows about dream-shifting but few believe it’s real, and where birthday-party magicians wield real magic, would be easier if its rules were more clear and consistent, or if potentially fruitful details–like the frequent mention of schisandra berries, or the growing of Gwendlyn’s antlers–were developed further to deepen readers’ understanding of Gwendolyn’s milieu and dilemma.
Gwendolyn’s dedication to and love for journalism is admirable, and her commitment to becoming a good interviewer is inspiring. Readers who enjoy chatty, casually fantastical storytelling or fast-paced antics are sure to find something to enjoy in this story. Best suited for readers willing to suspend their disbelief, Dream-Shifter is a quick and fun read with a spark of magic.
Takeaway: A fast-paced, action-packed story of a girl turning into an elk–and still trying to win her scholarship.
Great for fans of: Katherine Applegate’s Crenshaw, Bryan Chick’s The Secret Zoo.
Production grades
Cover: A-
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: B-
Marketing copy: A-