Theodosia "Teddy" Ballard knows nothing about community theater, but when the stage manager for "Little Shop of Horrors" takes a tragic header down the costume lost stairs, she agrees to fill in for the sake of her actor friend, Will. Then one night when Teddy is alone in the theater, she meets George Clancy Everhart, the theater ghost, who tells her the former stage manager was murdered, and he wants her to find the killer. Teddy's investigation, the rehearsals, and all the theater superstitions are complicated when she makes a surprising discovery about her sexual identity which impacts her relationship with Will. And it turns out George has his own dramatic agenda.