Assessment:
Plot/Idea: Kaalchakra speeds through Indian mythology and contemporary Mumbai, following two teens on a dizzying, soul-searching journey. The fast pace sacrifices buildup at times, but the story smoothly takes shape in Dhar's capable hands.
Prose: Dhar's sensory descriptions are rich and lyrical, awash in vibrant metaphor. The writing style creates some distance between readers and the story's characters, but it matches the premise well.
Originality: Dhar puts a fresh spin on everyday heroes and legends saving the world by raising awareness of the effects that an environment in turmoil can have on ancient historical sites.
Character/Execution: Main characters are an intriguing mix of complicated, flawed, and struggling with their own demons, as they serve a greater purpose within the overall narrative. Abhay and Vihaan offer readers an absorbing tale through their coming-of-age experiences, and their relationship is rich with deeper meaning.
Date Submitted: May 28, 2024
From there, Dhar swiftly raises the stakes—personal, spiritual, global—as Abhay and Ira, facing loss and terrifying visions, find themselves on a quest to “the gateway between Heaven and Earth on Mount Kailash,” guided by the riddling text on the tablet and pursued by the deadly forces of Kali Asura. Helping them along is each teen’s prophetic role as an incarnation of Kalki—Abhay has powers of destruction, and Ira has inherited powers of illusion, eventually discovering, in a clever inversion, that dispelling can be as powerful as conjuring.
As they master these skills, the action is fast, inventive, touched with poetry (“the time was ripe for unleashing her primal beast, her inner vigor and wrath and restlessness”) and occasional convoluted prose (the eyes of a parrot who is more than just a bird “whirl like a cyclone, before spiraling into a furious rotation like a spiral galaxy.”) But there’s much inventive vigor here, a deep engagement with demons both mythological and interior, and a rousing spiritualism. The characters burst with heart, and the storytelling is clear and exciting.
Takeaway: Epic fantasy of Hindu mythology, bursting with heart and invention.
Comparable Titles:Shveta Thakrar, Shiulie Ghosh
Production grades
Cover: A
Design and typography: B+
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A-
Marketing copy: A