Cameron spins a good adventure yarn, one that boasts a cozily creepy atmosphere, many good possible suspects for the villain, parents who extend patience and grace to their children, and the fun of figuring out which characters are of this world and which ones are not. Above all, the series turns on the Young Adventurers themselves, a group of friends who choose to stand up for each other and the greater good, even in the face of danger. The supernatural elements are scary but not overwhelmingly so, and the story is appropriate for its middle grade audience.
Cameron continues to seize the opportunity, in these books, to introduce readers to geographical and historical eras that may be unfamiliar to them and which may spark an interest in learning more. Even in 1917, this story reminds us, kids had their favorite movie stars (Charlie Chaplin, of course). This nice blend of fantasy and history is told in direct yet engaging prose that will draw young readers in to see what adventure awaits.
Takeaway: A ghost train powers this spooky historical mystery.
Comparable Titles: Linda Fairstein’s Devlin Quick series, Sharon M. Draper’s Clubhouse Mysteries.
Production grades
Cover: A-
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A