Assessment:

Plot: Surprisingly, the third book in this series offers a highly intriguing plot, as does not often happen with sequels. While still fast-paced, this installment was more thoroughly developed and emotional than A Sicilian Farewell, deepening and enriching the overarching narrative.

Prose: The author's heavy use of interrogative sentences and rhetorical cliff hangers is rather distracting. More variety in structure would benefit the book as a whole.

Originality: The narrative here falls in line with the previous two books, following a set path. The conflict in the story carries over from the previous installment. Certain conflicts, however, are new to the story and emerge somewhat abruptly. Regardless, the novel concludes on a satisfying note; though certain aspects of the novel are unresolved and open to imagination, this is in no way a detriment.

Character Development: While readers already engaged in the series will embrace the return of the characters, the novel deviates from rational character development in some respects. Notably, the work pins plot-convenient traits to individuals, somewhat reducing their complexity. Without precedent, Nico is turned into an irrational 'adult' who refuses to understand Maria's point of view, the hurt she has endured, and especially why she would be weary of Don Franco's re-entry into their lives. Maria is made almost hysterical and Luca is reduced to a two-dimensional being who had lost his empathy.

Date Submitted: August 07, 2019