Assessment:

Plot/Idea: Gibson's novel is well plotted and benefits from solid, precise world building. There are clear stakes and tension from the very beginning, which makes for a compelling page-turner.

Prose: The prose is descriptive and even literary. This fits well within the fantasy genre and for the unique world the author introduces—in an accessible manner—to readers. Gibson work is imaginative and compelling.

Originality: While The Blackened Yonder is in some ways similar to other fantasy series—and many of the good-versus-evil tropes have been seen before—there is much to distinguish this book from others in the genre. The world building is distinctive, the lines between good and evil are blurred, and reference to religion and the supernatural are original.

Character/Execution: Athenne is a very compelling character and we are drawn in by her journey as a "terrorist" from the very beginning. The relationship between humanity and the gods is unique and readers will easily identify with the cast of characters.

Date Submitted: August 30, 2024