As the title suggests, this fleet and exciting epic from Johnson (author of When the Magic Finds Them)offers fantasy in a classic vein, alive with weird beasts, wild magic, and a rousing spirit of adventure. Johnson’s tale follows six siblings—Aimee, Erik, Becka, Brian, Kami, and Adam—on a quest to confront the menacing dragon Gwandoya, whose dark presence threatens their family and homeland. As they venture into a mysterious realm filled with dangers and wonders, they encounter a diverse array of mythical creatures, from mugs to wizards, to hideous giants and pixies who can manipulate time, all as the heroes discover both their own hidden magical abilities and their courage, strength, and resilience. This is fantasy for readers who love to know the names of the horses.Johnson has crafted a vivid, enchanting world, both familiar and surprising, populated by mythical beings seamlessly woven into the story's fabric. Her detailed and playful world-building—featuring forbidden forests, charms and spells put to clever uses, Dreamcasters that project onto a wall, and spells—fully conjure a magical landscape that it’s a pleasure to visit. The story has the appeal of a treasure-hunt, with the siblings constantly on the lookout for magical tools that propel their journey forward, keeping readers hooked with every turn of the page, wondering how each new discovery will be set to the cause.
Pacing is brisk, with action commencing from the very first page and presenting the siblings with a steady stream of challenges. Dreams serve as a key motif, linking the magical world with reality, while Johnson’s clever use of hidden mysteries adds layers of intrigue and suspense, enriching the narrative beyond its fantasy tropes. The sibling dynamics are well developed, with each character’s strengths playing a crucial role and everyone growing throughout the saga. Legends of Caraigdun will resonate with readers seeking immersive world-building and the charm of classic fairytales, reminiscent of the bedtime stories told by a wise elder.
Takeaway: Inspired fantasy adventure in a timeless mode.
Comparable Titles: Patricia C. Wrede, Robin McKinley.
Production grades
Cover: B-
Design and typography: N/A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: B+
