At its heart, this is a daunting tale of parenthood, love, and devotion, one that reveals the power of unresolved trauma. Gwen, though stuck in a cycle of self-blame, continues to grapple with the emotional impact of unplanned motherhood; Zivi, while having committed to a crime-free life, cannot bear to witness Giselle’s sadness; and Giselle, even as she grieves for her child, cannot stop herself from falling in love with Gwen’s. Alongside the unraveling of the story’s three main perspectives is the unraveling of its central mystery, though, unlike traditional whodunits, this is a mystery that plumbs the motivations behind the kidnapping, the tangle of relationships that precipitated it, and the aftershocks it produces for the novel’s main characters. White skillfully builds on these layers, making readers question not only the morality of the crime, but who the real protagonist and antagonist are.
This is a unique crime-driven thriller that explores two contrasting sides to parenthood—nurturing and destructive—both of which play into not only Gwen’s downward spiral but also Zivi and Giselle’s shocking outcome. A must read for those interested in suspenseful novels with considerable psychological depth, White’s writing will entertain and surprise in equal measure.
Takeaway: A compelling psychological thriller exploring parenthood and trauma.
Comparable Titles: Celeste Ng’s Little Fires Everywhere, Sam Vickery’s The Perfect Baby.
Production grades
Cover: A
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A-